Paying for Performance: Why Commission Alone Isn’t Enough

Compensation is one of the biggest expenses in any practice, and one of the most common places I see owners struggle.

Often the plan was set up quickly, when someone was hired, and never really revisited. Or it’s commission only, because it feels safe: you only pay when someone produces.

But what you pay for is what you get.

What Commission Alone Rewards

Commission rewards the treatment in the chair. That matters, but it’s only one part of what makes a practice successful.

When pay is tied to production alone, it’s easy for providers to come in, see their patients and leave. Teamwork, helping out, showing up for marketing and being part of the culture aren’t part of the deal, so they often don’t happen.

A Better Balance: Commission Plus an Hourly Rate

The approach I recommend is a combination. An hourly rate recognizes the time someone gives to the practice as a whole. Commission rewards their performance.

Together, they encourage providers to grow their own book while still being part of the team.

Performance Only Works With Clear Expectations

Paying on performance means very little if nobody has defined what performance looks like.

Without clear metrics, reviews turn into negotiations, raises feel random, and frustration builds on both sides. With clear expectations set from day one, everyone knows what they’re working toward and how they’ll be measured.

No surprises for the provider. No guesswork for the owner.

Fair Doesn’t Mean Equal

Every member of your team should be treated fairly and with respect. That doesn’t mean everyone is paid the same. Experience, skill and the role someone plays in the practice should all be reflected in their pay.

The Bottom Line

A strong compensation plan does more than control costs. It shapes your culture, keeps good people and makes your practice more valuable, especially if you plan to sell one day. Pair commission with an hourly rate, define what success looks like, and revisit the plan as your practice grows.

Pay for the practice you want to build, not just the appointments on the books.

Want help building a compensation plan that works for your team?

Book a free strategy call now

Unlock Your Practice's Potential

I’m passionate about helping small businesses excel and expand while achieving their own short and long-term visions for their business